loading

Marketing for Small Business · Practical Guide Before Spending Ad Budget

How to Choose an Ad Agency: A Step-by-Step Guide

Marketing agency selection guide

If you run a store, a clinic, or an online shop, you'll eventually need to hire an advertising agency. There are tons of options out there, and every company presents things differently, which can make it feel overwhelming about who to trust.

In this post, we'll break down the different choices you have before picking an agency and explain which approach suits different business owners. We'll wrap up by covering essential questions to ask before signing a contract and how to check refund policies.

What to Decide Before Hiring an Ad Agency

An ad agency is essentially a service that handles your advertising for you. However, the scope of work varies wildly between companies, so it's best to nail down exactly what you want to achieve first. Whether you want more inquiries, more foot traffic to your store, or just want to promote a specific product, the type of agency you choose will change.

  • Set measurable goals, like the number of inquiries or reservations you want.
  • Decide if you want to pay for ads monthly or run a one-time campaign.
  • Determine what tasks you want them to handle—like writing copy, posting the ads, or reporting on results.

Ad Platforms vs. Advertising Agencies: What's the Difference?

An ad platform is the actual space where you place your ads. An advertising agency is the company that plans and manages the ads within that space. While running the ads yourself on the platform can save you money, you'll be responsible for everything: choosing keywords, creating the ad creative, and analyzing the results.

On the flip side, if you hire an agency, you save time, but if their operational methods aren't transparent, it can be hard to track where your ad budget is actually going. Because of this, figuring out whether to use a platform directly or hire an agency should be your very first step.

Category Pros Cautions Best For
Running Ads on Platform Yourself You have full visibility into the structure. It takes a lot of time to manage. When you have the time to manage the ads yourself.
Hiring an Ad Agency They handle the planning and execution. You must check their fee structure. When you don't have time to manage it yourself.

What to Look For When Using Mom Cafes for Promotion

If you run a local business or sell parenting-related products, mom cafe promotions might come to mind. Since mom cafes are places where parents in the same area gather, they can build trust easily. However, the moderators often strictly manage any posts that look like paid advertisements.

So, when hiring a mom cafe promoter, you need to check beforehand if the posting style looks natural, how many rounds of copy edits are allowed, and what the procedure is if the post gets deleted. If these three things aren't clear, your results could be worse than you expect.

Where Advertising Fits into the Overall Marketing Strategy

Advertising is just one piece of the larger marketing puzzle. If your product detail pages or store information are weak, increasing traffic through ads won't necessarily lead to actual inquiries.

Before you hire an ad agency, take a good look at whether your business introduction materials are solid enough. Here are some things you should have ready before handing things over to an ad agency:

  1. The core message of your product or service, along with your pricing structure.
  2. Any pain points or issues customers might face during the booking or purchasing process.
  3. Past advertising history and what the results were.

What to Watch Out For When Looking at Ad Agency Rankings

Lots of people search for the best-ranked ad agencies, but relying solely on rankings is risky. The criteria used to determine those rankings might not be public, or the rankings themselves could just be paid placements from other advertisers.

What matters more than the ranking is whether they have a proven track record of success in your specific industry, and if their reporting is detailed. Try lining up proposals from several agencies and comparing them based on the same criteria.

When to Discuss Refunds with an Ad Agency (Before Signing)

Most people searching for "ad agency refunds" are in trouble after the contract because the results didn't meet their expectations. Whether you get a refund depends entirely on the terms written in your contract, so checking those terms before you sign is the safest bet.

There are several key areas in the contract you absolutely must check:

  • How advertising costs will be handled if you terminate the contract midway.
  • What compensation or re-running conditions are in place if the performance doesn't meet the agreed-upon standards.
  • The limits on the number of times you can request copy revisions or cancel a post.
  • The deadline for requesting a refund and what supporting documents you need to provide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are the rankings of advertising agencies trustworthy?

If the criteria used to calculate the rankings aren't made public, you should only treat them as a general reference. Make sure to check both their industry experience and the format of their reports.

Under what circumstances can I get a refund from an advertising agency?

Whether you can get a refund depends on the cancellation clauses in your contract and the actual execution details. It's safest to get the refund policy in writing before signing anything.

Should small businesses hire an advertising agency?

If you have time to manage things yourself, try using the advertising platforms first. If you're short on time, we suggest starting with a limited scope agency contract.

Here are two things you should do right now. First, write down your store's advertising goal in one sentence. Second, reach out to two agencies you're interested in and ask for their refund terms and reporting methods in writing. Once you have comparison points, choosing one becomes much easier.