5 Things to Check Before Hiring a Marketing Agency

When you're running a business, there comes a time you need to hire a marketing agency. If foot traffic is down, you might not know where to start, and when you look at quotes or rankings from different agencies, they all seem so similar, which can be confusing.
In this post, I'm going to walk you through what you need to nail down before hiring an agency and what questions you absolutely must ask before signing a contract. We'll also cover some common pitfalls when looking at Instagram ad costs and agency rankings.
1. Write Down the Problem You Need to Solve in One Sentence
Before you start looking for marketing help, you need to clearly define what your biggest problem is right now. Whether you're struggling with low foot traffic from search, leads not turning into sales, or needing to bring back old customers, the work you need done will change based on your answer.
- Are you lacking new customers, or is your repeat business low?
- Is the issue with search visibility, or is it your landing page/consultation flow?
- Do you have room to increase ad spend, or do you need to spread the cost out?
Once you have this sentence clear, you can immediately judge whether an agency's proposal actually solves your specific problem.
2. What Affect the Cost of a Marketing Agency?
The cost of a marketing agency varies widely between companies, and even with the same agency, the price changes significantly depending on the scope of work you assign them. When reviewing quotes, it’s better to focus on what tasks are included rather than just the final number.
| Check Item | How It Impacts Cost |
|---|---|
| Scope of Work (Blog, Search Ads, Social Media, etc.) | The more channels you ask them to manage, the higher the cost. |
| Ad Spend Inclusion | You need to see if the management fee is separate from the actual ad budget. |
| Contract Length | Longer contracts can lead to different pricing structures. |
| Reporting Frequency and Consultation Style | The level of support you expect from the contact will affect your management load. |
When you get a quote, go through it item by item and mark what’s in and what’s out. This makes comparing different agencies much easier.
3. How Instagram Ad Costs Change Based on Your Goals
When you're looking into Instagram ad costs, you first need to decide how much exposure you want versus how many clicks or inquiries you're hoping for. Even with the same budget, your setup and results will change depending on whether your goal is just visibility or driving store visits.
Factors that influence the cost include:
- How narrowly you want to target the ad's location and age group.
- How many ad creatives you plan to prepare and rotate.
- Whether they will handle the follow-up after people inquire.
The cost structure for Instagram ads changes depending on whether you're just hiring them to run the ads, or if you need them to handle everything from creative production to performance analysis, so make sure to ask about this when you get quotes.
4. Take Ad Agency Rankings as Just a Guide
You can easily find lists of ad agencies, but just because an agency is high on a ranking doesn't mean they are the right fit for your business. Rankings are often based on general reach or brand awareness, and they frequently don't account for your specific industry, location, or budget.
When looking at these rankings, be sure to check the following things alongside the ranking:
- If they have experience working with clients in your specific industry.
- What metrics they use to report on performance.
- If the terms for contract termination or mid-campaign changes are clearly defined.
5. Key Questions to Ask Before Signing a Contract
If an agency can't give clear answers to these questions during your consultation, you should probably give it some more thought.
- What specific numbers will they aim for this month?
- What specific items will be included in the performance reports?
- If things get busy, who will be your point of contact and how will they communicate with you?
- What happens to the work deliverables if we decide to end the contract early?
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do marketing agencies usually cost?
It's difficult to give a single price because it varies greatly depending on the scope of work you assign them. Try comparing quotes based on the specific tasks included and whether the ad spend is included in the fee.
How should I determine the cost for Instagram ads?
The best approach is to define your ad goal first, and then allocate your budget to meet that goal. Another tactic is to start with a smaller budget to see how the audience responds before scaling up.
Can I just pick an agency based on rankings?
It’s best to treat rankings as just reference material. You need to confirm if they have experience in your industry and if their performance reporting process is clear.
What you can do right now is write down your business's main problem in one sentence and then lay out all the quotes you receive side-by-side by item. Just doing those two things will make your agency consultations much smoother.
